Did Whitey Bulger Pull Off the Gardner Art Heist for the IRA?
Private
detectives on the trail of 13 masterpieces stolen from Boston 30 years
ago are looking at what’s left of the Irish group. Others are skeptical
of the fantastic theory.
It’s
been nearly 30 years since two conniving art thieves dressed up like
Boston cops and sweet-talked their way into the city’s Isabella Stewart
Gardner Museum after closing hours. Once inside, they handily tied up
the museum’s two on duty security guards and carried out the biggest art
heist in modern history, stealing 13 masterpieces worth more than $500
million in a rather leisurely 80 minutes.
The heist, which
included works by Rembrandt and Vermeer, remains one of the biggest art
thefts on record and, three decades later, one of the most perplexing
mysteries art detectives have ever tried to unravel. The only real lead
the FBI has ever acknowledged receiving are some paint chips that were
sent by mail anonymously, consistent with the red lake in Vermeer’s “The
Concert,” which was cut with surgical precision from its frame the
night of the heist.
Some of the stolen works of art from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in the March 18, 1990, heist.
For
years, it was assumed that the artwork, if still intact, is in the
United States, likely part of an underground network being held for
eventual ransom or secret sale to rogue collectors of such hidden
treasures. But a $10 million reward offered by the museum has not smoked
out the culprits or current owners of the art, who are guaranteed by
authorities immunity and anonymity if they just turn over the
masterpieces.
Thousands
of tips have dissolved into false leads over the decades, but recently,
two of the biggest names in art recovery have hinted that the paintings
just might be in the hands of what’s left of the old Irish Republic
Army or IRA. No one agrees just how they got there, if indeed they are
there, which has complicated any chance of collaboration among those
searching to bring the art home to Boston.
FBI special agent Tim
Carpenter, who heads the bureau’s Art Crime Team, gave credence to the
theory that has for years been a hushed whisper when he told the Law & Crime website
the stolen artworks could “perhaps” be overseas. “I don’t think it is a
cold case because we do get a fair amount of information on that case,”
he said, though he would not elaborate on how close they may be to a
breakthrough.
Some of the stolen works of art from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in the March 18, 1990, heist.
His
veiled “maybe” echoed an announcement Dutch art detective Arthur Brand
made this spring, in which the acclaimed private detective said he had
spoken directly to members of the IRA who implied that with immunity and
the $10 million award offered by the Gardner museum, they would be
ready to give up the raided art. “The IRA is not a trustworthy
organization,” Brand told The Daily Beast recently. “But the
organization is dying and they need to liquidate now more than ever.”
Neither
Brand nor Carpenter will give much in the way of proof that the
paramilitary group–or what’s left of it–can guarantee they have the
goods. And Anthony Amore, the man in charge of the Isabella Gardner
Museum’s security, doesn’t buy for a minute that the art is in the hands
of the paramilitary group. “The IRA has been mentioned for 29 years,”
Amore told The Daily Beast. “But there is zero evidence that the IRA has
been involved. Everything points to the art being right here in the
United States.”
Bulger’s
attorneys have said he was ready to negotiate giving up some
information about the paintings in exchange for safer prison digs just
weeks before he was murdered.
Amore
says that informants, including lead figures of the IRA at the time of
the theft, coupled with historical information, leads him to believe the
theory is flat wrong. “They would take paintings like this to ransom
people or negotiate people out of jail,” Amore says. “They did not do
that when they could have.”
One theory about how the IRA could
have even possibly received the paintings is tied to James “Whitey”
Bulger, the former boss of an Irish-American mob called the Winter Hill
Gang that lorded over the South Boston area in the 1970s and ’80s.
Bulger, the story goes, may have given the paintings to the IRA as a
consolation prize after a shipment of arms to Ireland was intercepted by
American police.
Top:
James ‘Whitey’ Bulger Jr. poses for a mugshot on his arrival at the
Federal Penitentiary at Alcatraz on Nov. 16, 1959, in San Francisco.
Bottom: James ‘Whitey’ Bulger mugshot in 2011.
Bulger,
who was on the run for 16 years before being nabbed in Santa Monica in
2011, was killed in his prison cell last October while serving a pair of
life sentences for some 19 murders. His attorneys have said he was
ready to negotiate giving up some information about the paintings in
exchange for safer prison digs just weeks before he was murdered. He was
already an FBI informant on certain matters, but not on the Gardner
art, which calls into question whether he was really involved.
Some of the stolen works of art from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in the March 18, 1990, heist.
Charles
Hill, a former Scotland Yard detective who is now a private
investigator, believes that Whitey was an IRA sympathizer. He told the Guardian
that the gangster “loved to associate himself with the cause, and was
involved in arms deals and drugs shipments to the republic.”
Brand, one of the most successful private bounty hunters of lost art, has previously admitted
to The Daily Beast that he has a history of making deals with the
devil, forging ties with raiders and thieves, penetrating their networks
to negotiate the circumstances to bring the stolen treasures home
without incriminating the thieves. He recently returned a $28 million
Picasso stolen from a private luxury yacht 20 years ago by infiltrating
the network that was hiding it. He has had similar success recovering
two bronze horses stolen for Adolf Hitler by his Nazi goons to be placed
at the threshold of the New Reich Chancellery in Berlin, and a string
of other Nazi-era stolen art, all earning him the nickname “Indiana
Jones of the art world.”
FBI
posters displaying works by artists Johannes Vermeer and Edgar Degas
are seen during a press conference held to appeal to the public for help
in returning artwork stolen in 1990 from the Isabella Stewart Gardner
Museum in Boston.
He
does not believe that Bulger has anything to do with the theft or a
transfer of the art overseas. “At the time of the theft, the IRA was
running guns from Boston without Bulger’s knowledge,” Brand says. “Those
paintings were tucked into one of the vessels and they are still in
Ireland today.”
Amore disagrees, insisting that, whether Bulger
was involved or not, the art is still in the U.S. He says Americans are
“consumers of stolen art, not exporters of it.”
Brand’s
methods—successful as they may be—are not always agreeable to the
rightful owners of the art in question. Amore, who has dedicated his
career to the return of the Isabella Gardner art, says he doesn’t do
deals with thieves, even if it might mean the safe return of the
treasures. “Art hunters like Arthur Brand often negotiate with the
smugglers and thieves, but is that something you can condone?” he asks.
“Anybody that can help us get our art back and acts ethically to do so
is welcome, but the idea of paying thieves art is unethical.”
He
questions Brand’s proclamation that he has talked to anyone who still
has ties to the IRA. “Thieves, or anybody holding the stolen Gardner
art, can go through an attorney to get the reward,” he says. “I don’t
begrudge Arthur, he has the right to search for it. But there is no
reason to reach out to someone in the Netherlands that people holding
our art wouldn’t even know.”
Some of the stolen works of art from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in the March 18, 1990, heist.
Amore
believes that the time has come, now nearly 30 years later, for whoever
is holding the art to come clean. “Many old cases are solved when
someone has the confidence to come forward, isn’t afraid anymore,” he
told The Daily Beast. “What happens typically with masterpieces is that
they are recovered right away or a long time after, and we have now
reached the time when those involved in the actual theft are dead.”
Amore
believes that time is on his side and that the art will eventually be
recovered when whoever is holding it is ready to give it up. Thirty
years is a long time to keep such precious art, and he says he believes
the time will soon come when they want to get rid of it. He is not
convinced it will be discovered any other way after so long.
“When
you are looking for something that is missing for a long time, but an
inanimate object, you don’t have the same things on your side as you do
when you are looking for a person,” Amore says. “A person has to go out
of the house, a painting just sits until it is found.”
Almost three decades after thieves stole a half-billion dollars’
worth of art from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston, the
head of the FBI’s art theft squad says he’s not sure all of the 13
pieces remain in the United States.
Over the years, FBI agents have travelled to six continents in search of the missing art, which include works by Rembrandt, Vermeer, Degas and Manet.
The FBI recently conducted x-rays of a home in a western American state
where a tipster suggested the art was hidden; there have been a number
of highly-publicized searches and digs. All to no avail.
Special Agent Tim Carpenter could not say for sure whether the stolen masterpieces are still somewhere in the United States.
“Perhaps,” Carpenter said during an interview with the Law&Crime
Network. “Only perhaps?” he was asked. “Perhaps,” he answered.
Despite this, Carpenter rejected suggestions that the FBI’s investigation of the 1990 theft had gone cold or had been a failure.
“Certainly not, no certainly not,” he said.
Carpenter said finding the stolen Gardner art remains his number one
priority as the agent in charge of the 20-person FBI art theft squad. “I
don’t think it’s a cold case because we do get a fair amount of
information on that case,” he said.
In 2013, the FBI and the U.S. Attorney in Boston claimed they had
determined who stole the art and had a good idea of where it was hidden.
But since then, despite a $10 million reward offered by the museum,
there have been no arrests and none of the art has been recovered.
“We have had successes, lots of successes, historically with rewards,
but it hasn’t really seemed to nudge it loose on this case. So I’m not
quite sure what it’s going to take,” Carpenter told the Law&Crime
Network.
Whoever stole the art in the brazen break-in on St. Patrick’s Day
night in 1990 would no longer face prosecution given the statute of
limitations. And federal prosecutors have publicly said they would offer
immunity to anyone who would come forward with the stolen pieces now.
“We’re very interested in the safe recovery and the full recovery of all of that artwork,” Carpenter said.
To date, the only physical evidence the FBI has acknowledged
recovering are a handful of paint chips that the FBI has said are
consistent with a “red lake” paint known to have been used by the Dutch
artist Vermeer. His painting, The Concert, is considered the
most valuable of the paintings stolen from the Gardner, although there
is no direct link between the chips and that particular work.
The chips were sent anonymously to a reporter for the Boston Herald in 1997.
Carpenter says he is holding out hope that the case can be solved
before the 30th anniversary of the theft, which would be March 2020.
“I’d like to say that if we could solve that case, I might just up and retire. That might be my swan song,” he said. Ariel Tu and Nick Lindseth contributed to this report. https://lawandcrime.com/ross-investigates/head-of-the-fbis-art-theft-squad-not-sure-if-stolen-gardner-museum-pieces-are-still-in-u-s/
A print of the Rembrandt van Rijn, “The Storm on the Sea of
Galilee” from about 1633, oil on canvas painting that is among the
missing from the March, 1990 Gardner Museum break in. Courtesy of the
Dept. of Justice
FBI art heist agent says missing Gardner works may not be in U.S.
The
head of the FBI’s art crime squad said he’s not sure if all 13 pieces
stolen from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum on the Fenway are in the
United States.
FBI Special Agent Tim Carpenter, who heads the bureau’s Art Crime
Team, told legal news website Law & Crime the stolen artworks could
“perhaps” be in the U.S. or abroad.
It was 29 years ago, in March 1990 in the early morning after St.
Patrick’s Day, that two thieves posing as Boston police officers talked
their way into the museum, tied up two security guards, and vanished
with 13 centuries-old masterpieces worth more than $500 million. Stolen
artworks include Rembrandt’s “Christ in the Storm on the Sea of Galilee”
and Vermeer’s “The Concert.”
“We get a fair amount of information on that case; we still address a
lot of leads on that investigation,” Carpenter said. “It’s not that
uncommon … especially high-end, when we are talking really valuable,
really well-known pieces that were disappearing, going to ground for
decades before they resurface. We hold out hope that we will locate
those pieces.”
“We would really like to get those paintings recovered,” Carpenter
added. “We are very interested in the safe and full recovery of all of
that artwork.”
In 2013, the FBI and Carmen Ortiz, the former Obama-appointed U.S.
Attorney for Massachusetts, announced they knew the identities of the
two men who took the art. Since then, the museum has doubled its reward
to $10 million in 2017 for the paintings’ safe return. But the FBI has
not made any arrests and none of the 13 artworks have been recovered.
“As we have said in the past, the U.S. Attorney’s office will
consider the possibility of immunity from criminal prosecution for
information that leads to the return of the paintings based on the set
of facts and circumstances brought to our attention. Our primary goal
is, and always has been, to have the paintings returned,” Ortiz said in
2013.
Carpenter said: “We have had successes, lots of successes,
historically with rewards, but it hasn’t nudged it loose on this case.
So I’m not quite sure what it’s going to take.”
Next year will mark the 30th anniversary of the art heist. “I’d like
to say if we could solve that case, I might just up and retire. That
might be my swan song,” said Carpenter.
Carpenter’s team was also behind the successful recovery of Tom Brady’s missing jersey from Super Bowl LI in 2017 — found in the possession of a former Mexican newspaper editor who had media credentials for the game.
“It’s not historical and yet it has this huge cultural value for
people,” Carpenter said of finding Brady’s jersey. “It’s not about
intrinsic, monetary or market value of a piece.”
Why is FBI Still in the Dark 29 Years After the Biggest Art Heist in US History?
Two
men posing as police officers tricked their way into the Isabella
Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston on the night of 18 March 1990. They
stole 13 pieces of work worth US$500 million, none of which has ever
been recovered.
In 2013 the FBI held a high profile press conference
and said they had made a huge breakthrough in the search for the
paintings which had been stolen in what had become known as the Gardner
Heist.
Richard DesLauriers, special agent in charge of the FBI's Boston
office, said: "The FBI believes it has determined where the stolen art
was transported in the years after the theft and that it knows the
identity of the thieves.
DesLauriers added: "The FBI believes with a
high degree of confidence that in the years after the theft, the art was
transported to Connecticut and the Philadelphia region, and some of the
art was taken to Philadelphia, where it was offered for sale by those
responsible for the theft. With that same confidence, we have identified
the thieves, who are members of a criminal organization with a base
in the Mid-Atlantic states and New England."
That was six years ago. Since then the trail has gone cold again and
the makers of a well-researched podcast, Last Seen, have cast doubt
on the veracity of the information on which the FBI based their
announcement.
So are we any closer to finding out what happened that night and who took the artworks?
At 1.24am two men in police uniforms pressed the buzzer at the
Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston and claimed they
were investigating reports of a disturbance.
They were let in by dopey security guard Rick Abath, who was overpowered and handcuffed, along with another guard.
The two robbers took their time and picked out 13 masterpieces
from renowned artists such as Vermeer, Rembrandt, Manet and Degas as
well as a Chinese vase, known as a gu, dating from the Ming dynasty.
The two most valuable pieces were The Concert, by Vermeer, and Christ
in a Storm on the Sea of Galilee, the only seascape Rembrandt ever
painted.
Last year the Boston Globe newspaper and Massachusetts radio station
WBUR teamed up to produce a ten-part podcast investigation, Last Seen,
which examined virtually all the various theories and probes which had
been carried out into the Gardner Heist.
It also examined whether Abath was the "inside man" or just a
part-time musician who happened to be on shift in a museum where
security had become lax over the years.
Among the suspects identified in Last Seen were conman Brian
McDevitt, professional criminals George Reissfelder and David Turner and
Carmello Merlino.
Reissfelder's brother later told investigators he had seen a painting
he later identified as being Chez Tortoni by Manet in Reissfelder's
apartment.
Merlino ran TRC Autoelectric, a car repair workshop in the Dorchester
district of Boston which became a hub of criminal activity, including
cocaine smuggling and armed car robberies. Merlino,
who died in 2005, repeatedly indicated to FBI informants he knew what
happened to the paintings or could get his hands on them but went to his
grave taking whatever secrets he had with him.
The FBI's most recent investigation — which sparked the 2013 press conference excitement — centred on Bobby Guarente and an associate, Bobby Gentile.
Guarente died in 2004 but Gentile, 79, is still being hounded by the
FBI, most recently when he was arrested during a sting operation
in 2015.
Gentile's lawyer, Ryan McGuigan, told Last Seen his client was
completely innocent and knew nothing about the Gardner Heist or the
paintings and said if he did know anything he would have told the FBI
to get them off his back.
Kelly Horan, the co-host of Last Seen, said there was one theory she
would like to have explored — the suggestion that infamous Boston
gangster Whitey Bulger stole the art and later gave it to the
Provisional IRA.
Charles Hill, a former detective with Scotland Yard, told The Guardian
last year: "After a shipment of weapons and ammunition was intercepted
by the Irish navy off the coast of County Kerry in 1984, Whitey felt he
owed one to his friends in the Republic. I believe he offered them the
paintings."
Bulger, 89, was beaten to death by a fellow inmate only 24 hours after arriving at a prison in West Virginia in October last year.
Man linked to largest art heist in history freed from prison
HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) — A reputed Connecticut mobster who federal
authorities believe is the last surviving person of interest in the
largest art heist in history criticized government officials Monday as
he adjusted to being back home after finishing a four-year prison
sentence for weapons crimes.
Robert Gentile, 82, also maintained he knows nothing
about the unsolved theft of $500 million worth of art from the Isabella
Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston in 1990. He was released from federal
custody in the unrelated weapons case Friday.
"I had nothing to do with the paintings. It's a big joke," Gentile said in a phone interview from his Manchester home.
He also blamed federal prison officials for worsening
health problems that have left him unable to get around except in a
wheelchair, and he criticized law enforcement officials for seizing his
money and damaging his home during a raid in the weapons case.
"I'm all crippled up. They had me in a bed for a year chained up," he said. "I should have never been in jail. It's a joke."
Officials with the Federal Bureau of Prisons said they
were reviewing Gentile's comments but had no immediate response Monday.
An FBI spokesman in New Haven declined to comment. Update:
Federal prison officials say there is no evidence to support
mistreatment allegations made by a reputed Connecticut mobster who
authorities believe is the last surviving person of interest in the
largest art heist in history.
The federal Bureau of Prisons said in a statement Monday that it could find no support for the allegations.
"Mr. Gentile went to prison, he's been released, the investigation goes
on. We're not sitting around hoping he tells us what he may or may not
know." Anthony Amore Director of Security Gardner Museum
The art heist took place March 18, 1990, when two men
masquerading as Boston police officers got into the museum by telling a
security guard they were responding to a report of a disturbance,
according to authorities. The guard and a co-worker were handcuffed and
locked in the basement while the thieves made off with the art.
The missing pieces include Rembrandt's only known
seascape, "Christ in the Storm on the Sea of Galilee," and Vermeer's
"The Concert," one of fewer than 40 known paintings by the 17th-century
Dutch painter.
The FBI told The Associated Press in 2015 that two
suspects — both Boston criminals with ties to organized crime — were
deceased.
Investigators believe the paintings moved through mob
circles to Connecticut and Philadelphia, where the trail went cold,
officials have said.
Prosecutors have said another gangster's widow claimed
her husband gave Gentile two of the paintings. Authorities also have
said that Gentile talked about the stolen paintings with fellow
prisoners and once told an undercover FBI agent he had access to two of
the paintings and could negotiate the sale of each for $500,000.
But Gentile, who will be on federally supervised release
for the next three years, has publicly insisted he knows nothing about
the theft or where the paintings are.
Federal agents have searched Gentile's home three times,
including with ground-penetrating radar, in what Gentile's lawyer, A.
Ryan McGuigan, believes were efforts to find the paintings and other
evidence about the heist.
The weapons charges were filed after
authorities found several firearms at Gentile's home in 2016, which he
was prohibited from possessing as a previously convicted felon.
Gentile was sentenced to more than two years in prison in
2013 for illegally selling prescription drugs and possessing guns,
silencers and ammunition. In that case, prosecutors said federal agents
found in Gentile's home a handwritten list of the stolen paintings and
their estimated worth, along with a newspaper article about the museum
heist a day after it happened.
Images of some of the world’s
most coveted masterpieces by Rembrandt and Vermeer adorn the walls of a
cramped office in Boston’s Fenway. A name plate from the frame that held
Manet’s “Chez Tortoni” is propped above a keyboard on the desk.
They
are a source of inspiration and heartache for Anthony Amore, security
director of the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum. He has spent countless
hours in this small room on the fourth floor of the historic palace,
searching for clues in an agonizing quest to recover treasures stolen
years before he was hired to protect the collection.
“When
you are looking for something for a long time and it seems like an
impossible task, you need inspiration,” says 52-year-old Amore, whose
office is filled with reminders of the $500 million worth of artwork
stolen 29 years ago.
Suzanne Kreiter/Globe Staff
Boston, MA., 02/19/2019, Anthony
Amore is the security director of the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in
his office, which reflects his all-consuming quest to recover the
masterpieces stolen decades ago. His office has reporductions of the the
lost artwork, including a photograph of the painting The Storm on the
Sea of Galilee by Rembrandt. Globe staff/Suzanne Kreiter
A high-resolution color photograph of Rembrandt’s “The Storm on the
Sea of Galilee” mounted on foam board hangs over Amore’s desk. At 4 feet
by 3 feet, it dominates the room, but is considerably smaller than the
original 5-foot-by-4-foot seascape that was pulled from its frame by the
thieves.
The office walls are covered with smaller images of some of the
missing art. Brackets that once held the stolen “Chez Tortoni” in its
frame are now in a plastic bag on Amore’s desk.
Suzanne Kreiter/Globe Staff
The hardware that held the painting “Chez Tortoni” by Manet to the wall.
Two thieves dressed as police officers were buzzed into the museum in
the early morning hours of March 18, 1990, and tied up two guards on
duty. In addition to Rembrandt and Vermeer paintings, they got away with
works by Manet, Flinck, and Degas, as well as a bronze eagle finial
from atop a Napoleonic flag and a Chinese beaker, or “Ku.”
The window in Amore’s office overlooks Palace Road, where the thieves parked and were let in at the museum’s side door.
Suzanne Kreiter/Globe Staff
From his office window, Anthony Amore can see where the theives parked their car the night of the heist.
Scratches made by the culprits are still visible on a square
metal plate resting on a file cabinet in Amore’s office. The stolen Ku
had been mounted on the plate.
Advertisement
None of the artwork has been recovered, despite a $10 million reward
offered by the museum and promises of immunity for those who have the
stolen treasures.
There also are items in Amore’s office that
reflect his other passions: family, politics, history, and literature.
The Swampscott Republican — who made an unsuccessful run last year for
secretary of state — has a framed photograph on the wall of father and
son former presidents, George H. W. Bush and George W. Bush.
There
is also a postcard depicting Paul Revere, and a copy of President
George Washington’s farewell address, which Amore explains by noting,
“I’m an aficionado of the American Revolution. That’s my thing.”
Photographs
of his two daughters, Alessandra and Gabriela, and some of their school
artwork are also on display. A collection of books — including some
written by Amore — fill a book case. Many are about art and, of course,
art theft.
Amore says his office captures his interests, but “more
than anything you can see the amount of stuff related to the theft is
overwhelming. And that’s really what the theft is: overwhelming.”
Suzanne Kreiter/Globe Staff
In Anthony Amore’s office is his daughter's sketch of a detective with a magnifying glass hunting for the stolen art.
Even his daughter Gabriela’s sketch, drawn in 2008 when she was 11,
focuses on her father’s unrelenting search. It depicts a girl with a
pony tail, standing in front of an empty frame and peering into a
magnifying glass. She’s saying, “Now I will help my dad find stolen
paintings from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum and sleep in my dads
office for the night.”
‘When you are looking for something for a long time and it seems like an impossible task, you need inspiration.’
Amore says he never let anyone sleep in his office, but he has
solicited all the help he can get in his effort to recover the artwork.
Since
Amore took over as security director at the museum in 2005, he has
worked tirelessly alongside FBI agents and federal prosecutors to
recover the masterworks. He’s created a massive database with details of
every tip chased over the last 29 years.
Three file cabinets in
his office are jammed with folders labeled with names of suspects and
“people of interest,” an assortment of gangsters, petty criminals, and
art thieves.
In 2012, the museum opened a new wing and Amore was
moved to a spacious, modern office there. But, the original building,
built by Mrs. Gardner and opened to the public in 1903 drew him back.
He
said he feels more comfortable in the 6-foot-by-15-foot office, even
though it’s often hot and gets noisy when air blows through a ceiling
vent. It’s located above the galleries that he’s charged with
protecting.
“The collection is here,” Amore says of his location.
“Two floors below me is the empty ‘Storm on the Sea of Galilee’ frame.
This is where I should be.”
His office is on the same floor where
Gardner lived until her death in 1924. Her living quarters were
converted to office space, for use by the museum’s director, in the late
1980s. Amore’s office was previously a maid’s bedroom.
Suzanne Kreiter/Globe Staff
A framed photos of Isabella and Jack Gardner in Anthony Amore’s office.
Amore keeps a photo of Gardner and her husband, Jack, who
died before the museum was opened, framed on his office wall. It’s the
first thing he sees when he opens the door — another source of
inspiration to keep pushing to reclaim the art that belongs in the
museum she left in her will “for the education and enjoyment of the
public forever.”
In 1942, 95 paintings and nine stained glass
works — including works by Titian, Rembrandt, Cranach, Zorn, Vermeer,
and Whistler — were removed from the Gardner museum and sent by armored
truck to an estate in Center Harbor, N.H., for safekeeping during World
War II, according to the museum archives.
The museum’s
photographer, Joseph Brenton Pratt, took photographs of the paintings,
which were hung in their place until the originals were returned in
1944.
Today, a copy of Pratt’s black and white photograph of
Vermeer’s “The Concert” is framed and mounted on Amore’s office wall.
Amore says it was a gift from the late photographer’s son, Christopher,
providing added inspiration to fuel his hunt for the stolen original.
The
investigation is daunting, but Amore says he remains hopeful that one
day the stolen masterpieces will be back on the museum’s walls. He says a
veteran State Police detective speculated the key to the mystery is in
the old files.
Amore points to his cabinet stuffed with folders and says, “So the answer is in here.”
Suzanne Kreiter/Globe Staff
Anthony Amore, in his office at the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum. To his left is “Chez Tortoni” by Édouard Manet.
The turbo Paul Hendry plan from empty frames
makes the most sense to me. Drop ALL the conditions on the immunity
agreement. Especially 'works must be returned in "good" condition, as
judged by isg' - this gives the museum an arbitrary out clause to
prosecute and the current owners of the art know it.
And
second, there is zero chance all 13 pieces are currently in the same
place. Yet, the condition on the $10M is that all 13 pieces must be
returned (again, in "good" condition as judged by isg). It's bogus.
It's an impossible reward. Drop the conditions and provide a reward
value for each piece individually.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Dr No, Hans Heinrich "Heini" Thyssen-Bornemisz’s Stolen & Looted Art Collection
Jan.
5 – Somewhere between 1970-1985, a piece of art valued at $218,000 was
stolen from BYU campus. After being stolen the “Silver Chalice” was
sold between a number of different art dealers before finally landing in
Switzerland with Count Thyssen-Bornemisz’s collection. BYU negotiated
with Thyssen-Bornemisz’s estate and the piece of art was returned to
BYU.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Camille Pissarro painting hanging in the Thyssen-Bornemisza Collection Museum.
The Camille Pissarro painting hanging in the Berlin apartment of Lilly Cassirer, circa 1930.
Miami lawyer leads legal charge against Spain to return Pissarro painting looted by Nazis
Cassirer’s great grandson is fighting a legal battle with the Spanish
museum to return the painting. - The Cassirer Family Trust, public domain
“This is important in different
ways to many communities,” Zack said of the case. “Jewish and Cuban
families suffered, from the Nazis and the Casto regime. When we took on
this case, it had a significant meaning far beyond just one case.”
Tracking down Nazi-looted art has been a priority for world leaders, who this month celebrated the 20th anniversary of the Washington Principles, a treaty aimed at returning the pieces to their rightful owners.
Miami lawyer Stephen Zack
- Boies Schiller Flexner law firm
The Nazi regime stole an
estimated 600,000 paintings before and during World War II, Stuart E.
Eizenstat, a U.S. State Department adviser who helped establish the
treaty, said at the conference earlier this month. He told the
conference that at least 100,000 paintings remain unrecovered, according to the New York Times, and singled out five countries, including Spain, for resisting efforts to return art stolen by Hitler’s henchmen.
As U.S. deputy secretary of the
Treasury under the Clinton administration, Eizenstat urged Spain to
return the Cassirer family’s painting to no avail.
The odyssey of the Pissarro
painting began in 1900, when his exclusive agent sold the work to the
Cassirers, who owned a prominent gallery in Berlin. Lilly Cassirer
inherited the piece in 1926, and displayed it her parlor. By 1939, as
the Nazis were systematically destroying Jewish society and preparing to
unleash their war machine on Europe, Cassirer was forced to sell them
the painting for a paltry sum in exchange for safe passage out of
Germany.
During the war, the Nazis sold
the painting to an anonymous buyer. For decades, the Cassirers believed
the painting was lost, until a family friend in 2000 spotted it at the
Thyssen-Bornemisza museum.
So what happened? The painting —
today valued at at least $40 million — wound up in the hands of (Dr No) Baron
Hans Heinrich Thyssen-Bornemisza, a member of the famous German
industrialist family. Records show he had purchased the painting in 1976
from St. Louis collector Sydney Schoenberg through the Stephen Hahn
Gallery in New York.
Spain later bought
Thyssen-Bornemisza’s art collection for display at the government-run
museum that bears his name. The baron died in 2002. For years after the
painting was spotted, the Cassirer family repeatedly asked the museum to
return the painting.
It was not until 2005 that Claude
Cassirer, Lilly’s grandson, filed a federal lawsuit in Southern
California. A trial judge dismissed the case five years later, a
decision overturned in 2013 by a federal appeals court. Claude has since
died, but his son, David Cassirer, is now the plaintiff, along with the
United Jewish Federation of San Diego County.
“There is a widespread
recognition by civilized nations that is important to restore looted art
to the rightful owners. The Spanish government and the Spanish museum,
in this respect, is contrary to international norms. And frankly, it’s
reprehensible,” said lawyer David Boies , who also represents the
family..
Spain’s Thyssen-Bornemisza Musuem
cortesÃa
Leonardo Boix
In an unusual court room
scenario, the Los Angeles federal judge must rule under Spanish legal
standards. Spain and the museum will argue that Thyssen-Bornemisza
bought the masterpiece in good faith — that the baron never knew the
painting was ripped off from the family by the Nazis.
“No evidence of bad faith can be
found in the Baron’s ownership of the painting – during which time the
painting was publicized and publicly exhibited in international tours
between 1979 and 1986, and in the 1988 magazine Architectural Digest,”
the museum’s legal team, headed by Thaddeus Stauber, wrote in court
documents.
Stauber declined to comment before the trial.
The Cassirer family’s legal team must prove that museum was an encubrador — in Spanish law, an accessory to the theft of the art decades earlier.
They point out that
Thyssen-Bornemisza was a sophisticated art buyer who employed a cadre of
experts to examine works. When he bought the painting in New York, it
still had a label identifying it as part of the Cassirer Gallery in
Berlin. Within the art world, it was widely knownthat the Cassirer painting had been targeted by the Nazis.
“It was easy to find out this was looted,” Boies said.
In the years after the purchase,
Thyssen-Bornemisza also fudged details of the purchase to try and hide
that he knew the Pissarro was a stolen work of art, according to the
lawyers.
The trial is before U.S. District Judge John Walter, and is expected to last at least three days.
David
Cassirer is suing Spain’s Thyssen-Bornemisza Museum to recover a
valuable Pisarro painting that was stolen by the Nazis in 1939, and
later wound up hanging in the gallery.- Cassirer family.
The Gardner Art recovery needs to be taken out of the Govt/FBI and Gardner Museum's hands. The
private sector, in the shape of a Billionaire Philanthropist, needs to
step in with a private reward offer structured with a:
Philanthropist Gardner Art Reward Price List No conditions on reward payment No scrutiny.
All done with media co-operation in public. Banner headline the Philanthropist Gardner Art Reward Price List
Then
the Billionaire Philanthropist can hand back the stolen Gardner art
they recover, seek no Gardner Museum reward, and not reveal how they
recovered the said stolen Gardner artworks.
Introducing Jeffrey Gundlach, the Billionaire Philanthropist,
Renaissance Person whom I believe has the rescources and is best suited
to bring home the stolen Gardner Art, with a private reward offer to
counter the uncollectable Gardner Museum reward offer.
Not satisfied with just donating a record amount of money to the
Albright-Knox Art Gallery, philanthropist Jeffrey Gundlach now wants to
live near it.
The billionaire investment manager, who owns a $15 million estate in
the Pacific Palisades of Los Angeles, will use a 5,204-square-foot
mansion at 76 Lincoln Parkway as his home when in town.
Gundlach bought the 0.41-acre property through Frostridge LLC in 2017
from the estate of Susan F. Surdam, paying $950,000, and he's making
interior improvements.
The property is just a few blocks from the museum, but the founder of
DoubleLine Capital won't always be there, said attorney Sean Hopkins.
So now he's planning to carve out the rear 4,525-square-foot portion of
the property into a new lot, on which he'll put up a two-story detached
building with a three-car garage and a 1,120-square-foot caretaker's
apartment.
Both the existing 2.5-story house in front, which dates to 1926, and the new house in the rear will be stucco.
Plans by architect David Sutton call for adding a new uncovered porch
on the front facade of the existing house. The new balcony is designed
to mimic the home's original terrace and courtyard. The property is
in the Elmwood Village Historic District East.
If approved, construction by Omni-Craft Inc. – the Akron-based firm
owned by Gundlach's older brother, Drew – would cost $250,000 and would
last four months, according to an application to he Buffalo Planning
Board, which will review the project July 30.
The project received three variances from the Zoning Board of Appeals.
Gundlach donated $42.5 million to the Albright-Knox in 2016 to anchor
the museum's $100 million capital campaign, then added another $10
million commitment in 2017 when the museum increased its target to $155
million.
The
Gardner Museum reward offer started out as a private reward offer from
the auction houses Christies and Sotheby's so this would only be
reverting to the original private Gardner art reward offer. See link: https://www.nytimes.com/.../auctioneers-underwrite-reward...
Establish
an itemized reward price list showing the amount that will be received for
returning each of the stolen items, to accommodate the possibility that the 13 stolen
Gardner artworks are no longer together.
Reward Total $10 million
Vermeer
$5 million
Rembrandt
Storm on the Sea $3 million
Rembrandt
Lady and Gentleman in Black $1 million
Manet Chez
Tortoni $500,000
After
Rembrandt Obelisk painting $100,000
A bronze
eagle finial
(c. 1813–1814) $100,000
Small
Self-Portrait
by Rembrandt $50,000
An
ancient Chinese Gu $50,000
La Sortie
de Pesage
by Degas
$ 50,000
Cortege
aux Environs de Florence
by Degas $50,000
Three
Mounted Jockeys
by Degas
(c. 1885–1888) $50,000
And second, there is zero chance all 13 pieces are currently in the same place. Yet, the condition on the $10M is that all 13 pieces must be returned (again, in "good" condition as judged by isg). It's bogus. It's an impossible reward. Drop the conditions and provide a reward value for each piece individually.
https://www.bostonglobe.com/business/2019/03/12/office-focused-what-missing/AAZeqTF3M5DLvFZwU32tSL/story.html