Robert “The Cook” Gentile, the geriatric
gangster suspected of hiding information about the world’s richest art
heist — the robbery of $500 million in masterworks from Boston’s
Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum — will likely serve about a year more in
prison after being sentenced Tuesday on federal gun charges.
U.S.
District Judge Robert N. Chatigny told Gentile, 81, he was giving him a
break because of Gentile’s age and declining health.
Chatigny
sentenced Gentile to a total of 54 months, but gave him credit for the
nearly three years he served in jail while awaiting sentencing.
Gentile’s lawyer said that with credit for good time, he is likely to be
out in just less than 11 months.
Gentile gave an emotional plea
for leniency and a sentence that would have allowed him to return
quickly to his ill wife, who he said may have only a matter of months to
live.
“I
wish you could see it in your heart to let me go home to my wife and
maybe give her another six months” Gentile told Chatigny.
He said
his experience in prison has been horrifying. Gentile’s lawyer, A. Ryan
McGuigan, said Gentile had been hospitalized three times during his most
recent incarceration.
“Anybody else would have killed
themselves,” he said. “They didn’t kill me, they just chained me. It
made me a cripple. It made me an old man. I can’t walk.”
His voice cracking, he said “my wife, that’s all I want. Thanks.”
“You
have some good points,” Chatigny told Gentile. “Your love for your wife
is genuine. You have worked in lawful occupations. but at the same
time, you have continued to engage in serious criminal conduct and you
don’t really accept responsibility for it. It’s evident to me, this is
just who you are.”
In a long argument for leniency, McGuigan read
from a sealed legal memo that contained excerpts from secret recordings
of Gentile made by two FBI cooperating witnesses. McGuigan said the
excerpts show that Gentile repeatedly told the FBI through its
informants that he did not know where the stolen art was and could not
get his hands on it.
The recordings, which are sealed and not
available to the public, suggest that Gentile may have once had access
to the paintings but lost that access when an associate of his in Boston
died and Gentile went to prison.
McGuigan cited the following excerpts:
-
“My friend died and everything disappeared … I have to go find the
paintings. You are asking for something that is not even feasible. I
have to go out and find the paintings.”
- “I got to go to Boston to see that guy. I’d only be guessing.”
-
“I’ve been away a long time and I don’t know where it is. All the
people I used to run with in Boston are dead. I’d have to go to Boston
to see that guy.”
U.S. Attorney John H. Durham accused McGuigan of
“selective reporting of the facts. He said he would not disclose
excerpts of the sealed recordings that the government provided to the
court in rebuttal.
Gentile, an 81-year old mafia soldier with a
criminal record dating from the Eisenhower administration, has been
locked in a stubborn stand-off with FBI agents since 2010, when the
widow of one of his mob partners told agents she had been present a
decade or so earlier when her husband handed Gentile two of the stolen
paintings.
The FBI has been charging Gentile with successive gun
and drug crimes ever since, hoping — futilely, it has turned out — that
the threat of prison would persuade him to divulge something that could
help solve one of the the world’s great art mysteries. For his part,
Gentile has been mute, insisting he knows nothing about the heist or the
missing art — in spite of old age, dire health, lousy prison food, a
$10 million reward, failed lie detector tests and a growing body of
evidence to the contrary, much of it consisting of his admissions
recorded by FBI informants.
Chatigny sentenced Gentile Tuesday at
the federal courthouse in Hartford on two sets of gun charges. In the
first, Gentile is accused of selling a loaded handgun to a convicted
murderer who was cooperating with the FBI. In the second, his is
accused, as a convicted felon, of illegally possessing two handguns, a
machine gun and a silencer. He has pleaded guilty to all the charges.
Art Heist Suspect Sentenced on Gun Charges
A reputed mobster who is a "person of interest" in an infamous art Heist in 1990 was sentenced on Tuesday in another case.
MANCHESTER, CT — A reputed mobster who is a "person of interest" in
an infamous art Heist in 1990 was sentenced on Tuesday to
four-and-a-half years in prison on gun charges, a leading prosecutor
said.
John H. Durham, United States attorney for the District of
Connecticut, said that Ronert Gentile, 81, of Manchester, was sentenced
on Tuesday by U.S. District Judge Robert N. Chatigny in Hartford to 54
months of imprisonment, followed by three years of supervised release,
for firearm offenses, and for violating the conditions of his supervised
release from a prior federal conviction.
Judge Chatigny ordered GENTILE to serve the first six months of his supervised release in home confinement.
According
to court documents and statements made in court, on Feb. 10, 2012,
Gentile was arrested after a federal investigation had revealed
involvement in the illegal distribution of prescription narcotics,
Durham said.
Subsequent court-authorized searches of Gentile's
Manchester residence resulted in the seizure of 200 Percocet tablets
packaged for distribution, two .38 caliber Smith & Wesson revolvers,
a .22 caliber North American Arms revolver, a .22 caliber derringer, a
12-gauge pistol-grip shotgun, numerous rounds of ammunition, boxes of
12-gauge shotgun shells, five handgun silencers, other items and
approximately $22,000 in cash. according to case details.
Gentle entered a guilty plea to federal drug and firearm offenses
and, on May 9, 2013, he was sentenced to 30 months in prison, followed
by three years of supervised release.
On March 2, 2015, while on
supervised release, Gentile sold a .38 Colt Cobra revolver, which was
loaded with five rounds of Smith & Wesson .38 Special ammunition,
for $1,000 to an individual he knew to be a convicted felon, Durham
said.
The sale occurred at Gentile's residence, where the revolver had been hidden in a couch cushion, the prosecutor indicated.
Gentile
was arrested on a criminal complaint on April 17, 2015, and was ordered
detained. On April 28, 2015, a grand jury returned an indictment
charging him with possession of ammunition by a convicted felon, and
sale of a firearm to a convicted felon.
On May 2, 2016, FBI
special agents executed an unrelated federal search warrant at Gentile's
Manchester residence and seized a .22 caliber Browning semi-automatic
pistol, a 9mm Walther semi-automatic pistol, a .380 caliber RPB
Industries, M11-Al semi-automatic pistol, and an unregistered silencer,
Durham said.
On May 24, 2016, a grand jury returned an indictment
charging Gentile with one count of possession of firearms by a
previously convicted felon, and one count of possession of an
unregistered silencer.
On April 6, 2017, Gentile pleaded guilty to
one count of possession of ammunition by a previously convicted felon,
one count of possession of firearms by a previously convicted felon, and
one count of possession of an unregistered silencer. He also admitted
that he violated the terms and conditions of his supervised release,
Durham said.
Judge Chatigny sentenced Gentile to 42 months of
imprisonment for the three firearm offenses, and a consecutive 12 months
of imprisonment for violating the conditions of his supervised release.
Gentile has been detained since his arrest on April 17, 2015, Durham said.
Gentile is a reputed mobster who the FBI acknowledges is a person of interest in the daring theft of classic paintings stolen
from Boston's Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in 1990, a heist valued at $500 million by authorities.
One
art historian at the University of Connecticut, when asked what the
value might be, hinted that the paintings are priceless in some
respects.
See more about the daring art heist
here.